Review Highlights
Guest sentiment toward Showalter's Fly-In Outposts is strongly positive. Nearly every review is 4 or 5 stars, and the most common theme is loyalty. Several guests say they have returned for 7, 15, or more than 30 years, and some groups have gone since the early or mid-1980s. One group of twelve, ten of them first-timers, decided after a single five-day trip to make it annual. Forum, blog, and Facebook comments are just as favorable.
Guests most often praise the fishing. They describe it as excellent in both size and numbers, with steady walleye action, lots of 2-4 pound fish, and a 25-inch walleye reported. One blogger said dozens of walleyes were released in a day even after a cold front. Guests call the lodging and facilities great, and one guest says the owners keep investing in the outposts. Action and Irwin got new kitchen cabins, and new cabins are being added at many camps. Reviewers also single out the personal service of the Showalter family, including Eddie and Michael, along with the float plane flight and the hospitality at base. Guests mention many lakes and camps, including Action, Carroll, Cochrane, Irwin, South Rapids, Severn, and Hammerhead. They describe the setting as remote, with wildlife viewing as an added draw.
Complaints are few and minor. One guest reported cold weather around 45 degrees and wind on Action Lake in an otherwise good trip, a reminder that conditions in the north can be unpredictable. Another said his group once found a boat flooded on a portage lake because earlier guests had not pulled the plug. That points to guest carelessness rather than a flaw in the outfitter, but it is a reminder to check equipment on lakes reached by portage. One forum poster felt the need to defend the outfitter against the idea that the lakes are fished out, saying many guests keep returning. No review reports a serious problem with the operation. The outfitter suits walleye anglers who want numbers and quality fish, groups of friends or family, first-time fly-in guests (a mostly first-timer group of twelve was very pleased), and repeat visitors who like a familiar family-run operation.
Read all 16 reviews
Roger Cormier (MidWest Outdoors)
Feb 1, 2023
Blog
Memories of a Great Canadian Fishing Trip
Trip report from a three-day TV production stay at Showalter's Carroll Lake outpost with Michael Showalter. The writer describes awesome fishing and spectacular weather. They caught a steady stream of walleyes, including a 25-inch fish, at a spot near the camp called The Narrows. Even after a cold front changed conditions, they released dozens of walleyes over the day. The Showalter's float plane flight and hearty hospitality at base also got a mention.
This lake
Showalter's Outpost Updates
A repeat guest said his group once found a boat flooded on a portage lake because earlier guests had not pulled the plug. The owner is adding new cabins to many camps, and Action and Irwin both got new kitchen cabins the previous year. The poster was heading back to Irwin in late September.
This lake
Hammerhead Herb
Mar 22, 2008
Forum
Showlaters Fly In Service
His group has used Showalter's since the mid-80s, and he has gone personally since 1991 except for 3 years. They fish the Carrol Lake camp.
This lake
Showlaters Fly In Service
Curbis said his group of 4 had used Showalter's for 4 years and highly recommended them.
Outfitter overall
Showlaters Fly In Service
LASSH said he had been on multiple trips with Showalter's. In the thread he defended the outfitter: the lakes are not fished out, and many guests keep going back.
Outfitter overall
RE: showalters and severn lake
Big J called Showalter's a top-notch outfitter. He fished Action Lake in early June and Cochrane Lake in late June. He called both trips outstanding, with great facilities and fishing.
This lake
Illinois Fisherman
Mar 10, 2003
Forum
RE: showalters and severn lake
Illinois Fisherman said he had used Showalter's since the early 90s and was very pleased with the service and fishing. He had also been to Severn a couple of times.
This lake
RE: showalters and severn lake
An anonymous guest from north central Illinois said he had gone with Showalter's since 1991, and his group since the early 80s. He said he was quite satisfied and that they put a lot back into their outposts. He had not fished Severn himself but understood it to be a very good walleye lake.
Outfitter overall
Jeff Fletcher
Jun 23, 2000
Forum
Showalters fly in outpost in Ear Falls
Jeff Fletcher had returned from Showalter's two weeks earlier. He said the fishing was great but the weather was lousy, with cold temperatures around 45 degrees and wind. They fished Action Lake and caught lots of 2-4 pound walleyes.
This lake
Richard Kolp met Eddie last year, called him a great guy, and said he can't wait to fish Hammerhead this year.
This lake
MidWest Outdoors writer
Blog
A Walleye-Catching Mecca
Trip report on a return visit to Showalter's Fly-in Outposts, fishing a new outpost lake. The writer fished with owners Eddie and Michael Showalter for a couple of hours during the stay. He concluded that the whole trip was completely awesome, as he had expected.
Outfitter overall
Ron Schara & Raven, Host of Minnesota Bound
Outfitter
Testimonial 1
Endorsement from Ron Schara: at Showalter's you fly into a roadless world where the lakes are pristine and the fish are biting. Your fishing schedule is set by you.
Outfitter overall
The Vrieze's & The Nepsund's, Park Rapids, MN
Outfitter
Testimonial 4
After fishing several Showalter's outpost camps over 15 years, the group agreed they are the best. They praised the accommodations, the fishing and the personal service of the Showalter family, which will keep them fishing there for years.
Outfitter overall
Laura Lanoue and Mike Neeland, Ashkum, IL
Outfitter
Testimonial 3
A group of twelve, ten of them first-timers, flew into Carroll Lake with Eddie. The reviewer called it the most beautiful, untouched, serene place they had ever seen. They said the fishing was unbelievable for both size and numbers. After five days of fishing and wildlife viewing, the group decided to make it an annual trip. They called Showalter's and their crew some of the best people to show you the trip of a lifetime.
This lake
Grandpa Grant & Granddaughters, Randolph, MN
Outfitter
Testimonial 2
They fished with Showalter's for the previous seven years with family and called it a fantastic experience. After using several other outfitters, they found the one with the best service and fishing. They have fished and hunted out of Action, South Rapids and Severn Lakes, said all the trips were terrific, and are already planning next year's trip.
Outfitter overall
Ron Schara & Raven
Outfitter
Host of Minnesota Bound endorsement
At Showalter's, you take flight into a roadless world where the lakes are pristine, the fish are in a biting mood, and your fishing schedule is set by you!
Outfitter overall